The first rise: how long it takes, and how to tell when it is done
The first rise, which bakers call bulk fermentation, is where most sourdough goes wrong. The clock gets you close. The dough tells you the rest.
Why the clock is only a guide
The same dough can take four hours in a warm kitchen and nine in a cool one. Your starter's strength, the flour, and how much starter you used all move it too. The calculator gives you a time for your kitchen temperature, and you should start checking about an hour before it.
How long it usually takes
Two things set the pace: the temperature of the dough and how much starter is in it. From Ovenmark's model, for a starter at its peak:
| Kitchen | 10% starter | 15% | 20% | 30% |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 64°F (18°C) | 12 h | 10 h | 8½ h | 7 h |
| 68°F (20°C) | 10½ h | 8½ h | 7½ h | 6 h |
| 72°F (22°C) | 9 h | 7 h | 6 h | 5 h |
| 76°F (24°C) | 7½ h | 6 h | 5½ h | 4½ h |
| 80°F (27°C) | 6½ h | 5 h | 4½ h | 3½ h |
Wholemeal and rye flours speed it up. A starter used before or well after its peak slows it down.
Take the dough's temperature
Professional bakers do not set the oven timer by the room. They set it by the dough. Push a probe thermometer into the middle right after mixing. Around 75°F (24°C) is the target the calculator plans for. Every 5°F (3°C) above or below changes the rise by roughly a fifth, so a reading of 70°F (21°C) means adding an hour or more to a six-hour rise.
The fix is the water. If the dough reads cold, use warmer water next time; the calculator gives you a water temperature for your kitchen.
The small-glass trick
A big tub of dough is hard to read. After mixing, pinch off about 40 g, drop it into a small straight-sided glass, press it flat and mark the level with tape. It rises at the same pace as the main dough, and you can see exactly how far it has grown. Bakers call this sample an aliquot. Use the dough's other signs too, but the glass ends most of the guesswork.
Five signs, in order of how much to trust them
- Growth. The dough has risen by about half to three quarters. Not doubled: that is usually too far for sourdough. Aim for the lower end, about 50%, if the loaf will spend the night in the fridge, because it keeps rising while it chills. Aim for about 75% if it will have its final rise on the counter.
- The wobble. Shake the tub gently. A ready dough wobbles like jelly. An unready one sits like a lump.
- A domed top. The surface curves up at the edges and looks smooth and alive.
- Bubbles. You can see them at the sides and a few on top.
- The feel. When you lift an edge with a wet hand, the dough feels airy and light, and pulls away from the tub cleanly.
Too early, or too late?
| Shaped too early | Shaped too late | |
|---|---|---|
| The dough | Dense, tight, hard to stretch | Slack, sticky, will not hold a shape |
| The loaf | Heavy, with a few big holes in a tight crumb | Flat, spreading, pale, very sour |
| What to do next time | Wait longer, or keep the dough warmer | Shape sooner, use less starter, or cooler water |
If you are unsure, slightly early is the safer mistake when the loaf will spend the night in the fridge, because it keeps rising slowly there.
What the folds are for
Folding the dough every half hour for the first two hours builds strength without kneading. Each fold lines the dough up and traps gas. After four folds, leave it alone so the bubbles can grow.
You can feel the strength build. After the first fold the dough slumps flat within minutes. By the fourth it holds a rounded shape in the tub and feels smoother and springier under a wet hand. If it still spreads like batter after four folds, give it one or two more.
Cold kitchen, slow dough
Below about 68°F (20°C), the first rise can take most of a day. Three things help: mix with warmer water so the dough starts at 75 to 78°F (24 to 26°C), keep the tub in an oven with only the light on (check it with a thermometer: some run hot), or use more starter. The calculator shows how each one changes the time.
Keep going
Sources
- King Arthur Baking, Desired dough temperature
- Everything not linked above is Ovenmark's own working, explained on How we work it out.