When the dough goes wrong: causes and fixes
Most dough problems come from four things: too much or too little time, temperature, water, or handling. Find your problem below, fix today's pizza, and change one thing next time.
While mixing
| What you see | Why | Do this now | Next time |
|---|---|---|---|
| Too sticky to knead | High hydration, or a soft flour that holds less water | Wet your hands. Rest the dough 20 minutes, then knead again. | Lower the hydration by 2 to 3 points, or use a stronger flour |
| Dry, stiff, will not come together | Too little water, or flour measured by cup | Add water a teaspoon at a time | Weigh everything |
| Tears when you stretch a small piece thin | Not kneaded enough yet | Knead 3 to 5 more minutes, or rest it and fold it twice | Give the dough a 20 minute rest before kneading |
While rising
| What you see | Why | Do this now | Next time |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hardly grown at all | Cold kitchen, very cold fridge, old yeast, or water that was too hot | Move it somewhere warm and wait. It is slow, not ruined. | Enter your real kitchen and fridge temperatures; test your yeast |
| Huge, bubbly, smells of beer, collapses when touched | Over-risen: too much yeast, too warm, or too long | Reshape the balls gently, rest one hour, and bake. Or bake it in an oiled pan. | Use less yeast, or shorten the plan |
| Dry skin on top | The tub was not covered | Wet your hands and smooth the skin under when shaping | Use a lid or oiled film |
| Balls have run into each other | Tub too small, or a very wet dough | Cut them apart with a scraper | One tub per ball |
Dough rising much faster or slower than your plan? When plans change shows how to hold it back or hurry it up, and the pizza calculator can work out a new plan for dough you have already made.
While stretching
| What you see | Why | Do this now | Next time |
|---|---|---|---|
| Springs back and will not stay stretched | Still cold, or just reshaped, so the dough is tight | Cover it and wait 10 to 15 minutes, then try again | Take it out of the fridge earlier |
| Tears into holes | Over-risen, or stretched too thin in the middle | Pinch the hole shut and press outward from the centre, not down | Shorter plan or less yeast; keep the centre thicker |
| Sticks to the peel | Too long on the peel, or too little flour underneath | Lift an edge, throw flour or semolina under, and shake | Top it quickly; shake the peel before every topping |
After baking
| What you see | Why | Next time |
|---|---|---|
| Pale base, cooked top | The baking surface was not hot enough | Heat the steel, stone or tray for the full time; try a lower shelf |
| Pale all over | Oven not hot enough, or a dough with no sugar baked on a tray | Highest setting; choose "home oven" in the calculator so the dough is made to brown |
| Hard, cracker-like crust | Baked too long at low heat, or hydration too low for a home oven | More water in the dough; a hotter surface and a shorter bake |
| Soggy middle | Too much sauce or wet toppings | Less sauce; drain fresh mozzarella on paper first |
| Dense, bready rim with no bubbles | Under-risen, or the air was pressed out when shaping | Longer on the counter before baking; leave the rim untouched when you stretch |
The one habit that fixes most of this
Change one thing at a time and write it down. Dough responds to small changes, and you only learn which change mattered if you made one.
Open the pizza dough calculator
Keep going
Sources
- Everything not linked above is Ovenmark's own working, explained on How we work it out.