ovenmark

Guides

When the dough goes wrong: causes and fixes

Most dough problems come from four things: too much or too little time, temperature, water, or handling. Find your problem below, fix today's pizza, and change one thing next time.

While mixing

What you seeWhyDo this nowNext time
Too sticky to kneadHigh hydration, or a soft flour that holds less waterWet your hands. Rest the dough 20 minutes, then knead again.Lower the hydration by 2 to 3 points, or use a stronger flour
Dry, stiff, will not come togetherToo little water, or flour measured by cupAdd water a teaspoon at a timeWeigh everything
Tears when you stretch a small piece thinNot kneaded enough yetKnead 3 to 5 more minutes, or rest it and fold it twiceGive the dough a 20 minute rest before kneading

While rising

What you seeWhyDo this nowNext time
Hardly grown at allCold kitchen, very cold fridge, old yeast, or water that was too hotMove it somewhere warm and wait. It is slow, not ruined.Enter your real kitchen and fridge temperatures; test your yeast
Huge, bubbly, smells of beer, collapses when touchedOver-risen: too much yeast, too warm, or too longReshape the balls gently, rest one hour, and bake. Or bake it in an oiled pan.Use less yeast, or shorten the plan
Dry skin on topThe tub was not coveredWet your hands and smooth the skin under when shapingUse a lid or oiled film
Balls have run into each otherTub too small, or a very wet doughCut them apart with a scraperOne tub per ball

Dough rising much faster or slower than your plan? When plans change shows how to hold it back or hurry it up, and the pizza calculator can work out a new plan for dough you have already made.

While stretching

What you seeWhyDo this nowNext time
Springs back and will not stay stretchedStill cold, or just reshaped, so the dough is tightCover it and wait 10 to 15 minutes, then try againTake it out of the fridge earlier
Tears into holesOver-risen, or stretched too thin in the middlePinch the hole shut and press outward from the centre, not downShorter plan or less yeast; keep the centre thicker
Sticks to the peelToo long on the peel, or too little flour underneathLift an edge, throw flour or semolina under, and shakeTop it quickly; shake the peel before every topping

After baking

What you seeWhyNext time
Pale base, cooked topThe baking surface was not hot enoughHeat the steel, stone or tray for the full time; try a lower shelf
Pale all overOven not hot enough, or a dough with no sugar baked on a trayHighest setting; choose "home oven" in the calculator so the dough is made to brown
Hard, cracker-like crustBaked too long at low heat, or hydration too low for a home ovenMore water in the dough; a hotter surface and a shorter bake
Soggy middleToo much sauce or wet toppingsLess sauce; drain fresh mozzarella on paper first
Dense, bready rim with no bubblesUnder-risen, or the air was pressed out when shapingLonger on the counter before baking; leave the rim untouched when you stretch

The one habit that fixes most of this

Change one thing at a time and write it down. Dough responds to small changes, and you only learn which change mattered if you made one.

Open the pizza dough calculator

Keep going

When plans change: rescuing doughWhat hydration meansCold fermenting pizza dough

Sources