ovenmark

Guides

A starter from scratch: flour, water and about ten days

You do not need to buy a starter or be given one. Flour and water, fed daily in a warm place, will grow their own yeast. It takes one to two weeks, and most of that is waiting.

What you need

Day by day

DayWhat to doWhat you will probably see
1Mix 50 g wholemeal flour and 50 g water. Cover loosely.Nothing
2Leave it alone.A few bubbles, perhaps
3Keep 50 g, discard the rest. Add 50 g flour and 50 g water.Often a burst of bubbles and a strong smell
4 to 6Repeat the day 3 feed once a day. Switch to white bread flour.It often goes quiet. This is normal, and it is where most people give up
7 to 10Feed twice a day, about 12 hours apart, the same way.It starts to rise and fall on a regular rhythm, and smells pleasantly sour
10 to 14Keep feeding twice a day.It doubles within 4 to 8 hours of a feed

The quiet days

The early bubbles on day 2 or 3 are mostly bacteria that do not last. When they die back, the jar looks dead for a few days. It is not. The yeast you want is slower to establish. Keep feeding on schedule and it arrives.

When it is ready

A starter is ready to bake with when, for three feeds in a row, it:

Smells and colours

You noticeIt meansDo this
Nail polish or sharp vinegar smellIt is hungryFeed more often, or with a bigger share of flour
Grey or brown liquid on topIt is hungry; the liquid is harmless alcoholStir it in or pour it off, then feed
Cheesy or sock smell in the first weekEarly bacteria, on their way outKeep going
Pink or orange streaks, or fuzzy mouldIt has spoiledThrow it away, wash the jar well, and start again

Why discard?

If you never discard, you must feed an ever larger jar, and the starter turns sour and sluggish. Keeping only a small amount and feeding it fresh flour keeps the yeast strong. Once your starter is established, the discard is useful in pancakes, crackers and flatbreads.

After that

Once it is reliable, you can keep it in the fridge and feed it once a week. The feeding guide covers ratios and timing, and the feeding calculator tells you when to feed for the time you want to bake.

Open the sourdough calculator

Keep going

Feeding a sourdough starterStarter feeding calculatorRecipe: everyday sourdough loaf

Sources