Instant, active dry or fresh yeast: which to use, and how to swap them
All three are the same living thing in different packaging. Any of them makes excellent pizza. What changes is how much you use and how you add it.
The short answer
Buy instant yeast if you have a choice. It keeps for months, goes straight into the flour, and is the easiest to measure in the tiny amounts that a slow dough needs.
The three types
| Type | What it looks like | How to add it | How long it keeps |
|---|---|---|---|
| Instant | Fine dry grains | Mix into the flour | Months in a sealed jar in the fridge or freezer |
| Active dry | Larger dry grains | Stir into a little of the recipe's water first, wait a few minutes | Months, kept the same way |
| Fresh (cake) | A soft, crumbly beige block | Crumble into the water and stir until it disappears | About two weeks in the fridge |
How to swap one for another
Fresh yeast is mostly water, so you need more of it by weight. Ovenmark uses these ratios:
| If the recipe says | Instant | Active dry | Fresh |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 g instant | 1 g | 1.25 g | 3 g |
| 1 g active dry | 0.8 g | 1 g | 2.4 g |
| 1 g fresh | 0.33 g | 0.4 g | 1 g |
Sources do not agree exactly. You will see fresh yeast given as anything from 2.5 to 3 times instant, and active dry as 1.25 to 1.33 times. The rules for certified Neapolitan pizza use one part dry to three parts fresh, which is the ratio Ovenmark follows. The gap between the ratios is smaller than the effect of a kitchen that is two degrees warmer, so pick one and stay with it.
Why the calculator gives such a small amount
A packet recipe that rises in an hour uses about 7 g of yeast for 500 g of flour. A dough that spends a day mostly in the fridge needs about 1.2 g, and a two-day dough about 0.6 g. The yeast has many more hours to work, so a little goes a long way. Use the packet amount in a 24-hour dough and it will rise too far, collapse, and taste of alcohol. The yeast chart gives the amount for every plan length and kitchen temperature.
How to measure half a gram
Most kitchen scales read to the nearest gram, which is not fine enough. Three ways around it:
- A pocket scale that reads to 0.01 g. This is the best answer and they are inexpensive.
- The water trick. Weigh 1 g of yeast into 99 g of water and stir. Every 10 g of that water now holds 0.1 g of yeast. If you need 0.5 g of yeast, use 50 g of the yeast water and take 50 g off the water in your recipe. Throw the rest away.
- A measuring spoon. A level teaspoon of instant yeast is about 3 g, so a quarter teaspoon is about 0.8 g. This is rough, and the calculator shows the spoon amount beside the weight when you use US units.
Is my yeast still alive?
Stir a pinch into a little warm water with a pinch of sugar. Live yeast foams within ten minutes. Dry yeast that has sat open in a cupboard for a year often fails this test. Keep it sealed and cold.
Open the pizza dough calculator
Keep going
Sources
- Associazione Verace Pizza Napoletana, International Regulation (2024)
- King Arthur Baking, How to bake with fresh yeast
- Everything not linked above is Ovenmark's own working, explained on How we work it out.