ovenmark

Recipes

New York-style pizza

New York pizza is wide, thin and foldable, with a crisp base and a chewy rim. The character comes from bread flour, a little oil, and two days in the fridge.

Makes3 pizzas of about 14 inches (35 cm)
Start to table48 hours 15 minutes
Your timeAbout 45 minutes
Hydration62%
OvenHome oven with a steel or stone, 500 to 550°F (260 to 290°C)

Ingredients

Bread flour12.5 to 14% protein; strong white flour in the UK
573 g
WaterAt about 79°F (26°C)
355 g
Fine saltAbout 2½ teaspoons
14 g
Olive oilAbout 2½ teaspoons
11.5 g
SugarAbout 1½ teaspoons
6 g
Instant yeastA level ¼ teaspoon
0.72 g

Weigh everything, including the water. Cups are too rough for dough. Open this recipe in the calculator and every weight and time changes to match.

Timeline

WhenWhat
6:45 PM, day 1Mix and knead
7:05 PMRest in the bowl for 2 hours
9:05 PMShape 3 balls, into the fridge
Day 2Nothing. The fridge does the work
3:45 PM, day 3Take the dough out
5:45 PMHeat the oven and steel
6:45 PMStretch, top and bake
7:00 PMEat

Method

  1. Mix and knead. Stir the yeast into the flour. Add the water, then the salt, then the oil and sugar. Mix until no dry flour is left, rest 10 minutes, then knead for about 10 minutes until smooth and only slightly sticky. Stretch a small piece thin: if it tears at once, knead a little longer. A probe thermometer pushed into the finished dough should read 74 to 77°F (23 to 26°C). Warmer and the dough will run ahead of this timeline; cooler and it will lag
  2. Rest on the counter. Cover the bowl and leave it for 2 hours. The dough will relax and start to puff
  3. Shape into balls. Divide into 3 pieces of 320 g. Tuck the edges under each piece and drag it toward you on a bare counter until the top is tight and smooth. Put each ball in a lightly oiled tub with a lid, with room to grow
  4. Into the fridge. Refrigerate for about 42 to 43 hours, two nights. The balls will grow by roughly half and flatten a little
  5. Take the dough out. Three hours before you bake, put the tubs on the counter. Cold dough fights back when stretched. It is ready when a gentle poke leaves a dent that fills back slowly
  6. Heat the oven. Put a baking steel or stone on an upper shelf and heat the oven to its highest setting for a full hour
  7. Stretch wide. Flour a ball. Press it out flat, leaving a narrow rim. Drape it over the backs of your hands and turn it, letting gravity stretch it to about 14 inches. It should be thin enough to see light through the centre
  8. Top and bake. Move to a floured peel. Spread a thin layer of sauce almost to the edge and cover with grated low-moisture mozzarella. Bake 6 to 8 minutes, turning once, until the cheese is bubbling and browned in spots and the base is crisp

Sauce and cheese

New York sauce is cooked and seasoned: simmer a 14 oz (400 g) can of crushed tomatoes with a crushed garlic clove, a teaspoon of dried oregano, a pinch of sugar and salt for 15 minutes. The cheese is low-moisture mozzarella, grated, about 5 oz (140 g) per pizza. Fresh mozzarella is too wet for this style.

Tips

Open this recipe in the calculator

Keep going

Guide: cold fermentingGuide: how much yeast for pizza doughRecipe: Detroit-style pan pizza

The weights and times on this page come from Ovenmark's dough model, explained on How we work it out. Flour, yeast, fridges and ovens all vary, so use the checks in each step and trust the dough over the clock. Tell us how yours turned out: [email protected].