Good pizza from an ordinary oven
A pizzeria oven is more than twice as hot as yours. You cannot fix that, but you can work with it: store heat under the pizza, bake high in the oven, and use a dough made for a longer bake.
The problem in one line
A wood-fired oven cooks a pizza in about ninety seconds. A home oven, which usually tops out between 500 and 550°F (260 to 290°C), takes five to ten minutes. In that time the base can dry out before the top has browned.
What to bake on
| Surface | How it performs | Heat it for | Bake time |
|---|---|---|---|
| Baking steel | The best. Steel passes heat into the base very fast, so the bottom browns and puffs. | 1 hour | 5 to 7 minutes |
| Pizza stone | Good. Slower than steel, and it can crack if it gets wet while hot. | 1 hour | 6 to 8 minutes |
| Heavy tray, upside down | Works. Use the thickest tray you own, turned over so the pizza slides on and off. | 45 minutes | 8 to 10 minutes |
Whatever you use, it must be in the oven from cold and heated for the full time. The air reaches temperature in fifteen minutes. The metal or stone takes far longer, and that stored heat is what cooks the base.
Where to put it
Use an upper shelf, about a hand's width below the top element. The top of the oven is the hottest part, and the pizza needs heat from above as much as from below.
If your oven has a grill (called a broiler in the US), switch to it for the last minute or two. It browns the top the way a flame would. Watch it the whole time, because it goes from pale to burnt quickly.
Change the dough, too
The dough that suits a pizza oven is wrong for a home oven. For the longer bake you want:
- More water. Around 65 to 68% hydration, so the crumb stays soft.
- A little oil. It keeps the crust tender.
- A little sugar, if you bake on a tray. It helps the crust brown at lower heat.
Traditional Neapolitan dough has no oil or sugar at all, and the certified recipe forbids them. That recipe is built for an oven you probably do not have. When you choose a home oven in the calculator, it makes these changes for you and says so; choose "pizza oven" and it returns to the traditional recipe.
Getting the pizza in
- Stretch the dough on the counter, then move it to a peel or a sheet of baking paper before you add toppings.
- Dust the peel with semolina or flour, and give it a small shake after topping. If the pizza does not slide, lift an edge and add more underneath.
- Go light on toppings. A wet, heavy pizza steams instead of baking.
- Baking paper is a fair shortcut. Slide the pizza in on the paper and pull the paper out after two minutes.
Is it done?
Lift an edge with a spatula. The underside should be browned with darker spots, not pale. The rim should be puffed and coloured. If the top is done and the base is pale, your surface was not hot enough: heat it longer next time, or move the pizza to a lower shelf for a final minute.
Open the pizza dough calculator
Keep going
Sources
- Associazione Verace Pizza Napoletana, International Regulation (2024)
- Everything not linked above is Ovenmark's own working, explained on How we work it out.