Which flour to buy: a baker's guide to protein, 00 and strength
Flour decides how much water a dough can hold, how far it stretches, how long it can ferment and how it browns. The label tells you most of what you need, once you know which two numbers to read.
The short answer
| You are making | Buy | The numbers to look for |
|---|---|---|
| Neapolitan, pizza oven | An Italian pizzeria 00, such as Caputo Pizzeria | The Neapolitan rules ask for 11 to 13.5% protein and a strength (W) of 250 to 320. Caputo Pizzeria lists 12.5% and W 260/270 |
| Neapolitan-style, home oven | Bread flour (strong white in the UK), or a pizzeria 00 with a little sugar for colour | King Arthur's bread flour is 12.7% |
| New York | Bread flour, or high-gluten flour for more chew | King Arthur's high-gluten flour is 14.2% |
| Roman thin | All-purpose (plain in the UK) | King Arthur's all-purpose is 11.7% |
| Detroit pan, focaccia | Bread flour | About 12.7%, like King Arthur's |
| Sourdough bread | Bread flour, with a little wholemeal for flavour | King Arthur's whole wheat is 13.2% |
Number one: protein
When flour meets water, two of its proteins, glutenin and gliadin, bond into gluten, the stretchy network that traps gas. More protein means a stronger, chewier dough that stands up to a long ferment. Less protein means a softer dough that is easier to roll thin and tears more readily.
| US name | UK name | King Arthur's protein |
|---|---|---|
| Pastry flour | Soft flour | 8% |
| Cake flour | Soft flour | 10% |
| All-purpose flour | Plain flour | 11.7% |
| Bread flour | Strong white bread flour | 12.7% |
| High-gluten flour | Very strong flour | 14.2% |
Brands vary within each name. King Arthur's all-purpose, at 11.7%, is stronger than many brands' all-purpose. Read the number on the bag, not the name.
What "00" really means
Italian flours are graded 00, 0, 1, 2 and integrale by ash content: how thoroughly the bran has been sifted out. As Caputo puts it, 00 is the most sifted, made only from the endosperm, and Italian flours still vary in protein just as American ones do. So 00 tells you how white and refined a flour is, not how strong. King Arthur's own Type 00 is 11% protein; Caputo Pizzeria is 12.5%. A 00 sold for pasta or pastry will make a weak pizza dough. Look for the word pizzeria, or for the protein and W numbers.
Number two: W, the strength number
Italian professional flours often print a W value, measured on a machine that inflates a bubble of dough until it bursts. Ooni publishes a rough guide to how long a dough can ferment for each W:
| W | Fermentation, per Ooni's guide |
|---|---|
| 200 | 6 to 12 hours |
| 250 | 12 to 30 hours |
| 270 | 12 to 36 hours |
| 300 | 16 to 47 hours |
| 320 | 20 to 54 hours |
| 350 | 24 to 65 hours |
Caputo Pizzeria, at W 260/270, sits in the 12 to 36 hour band, which fits the Neapolitan rules' 12 to 24 hours of fermentation. For a two- or three-day dough, look for a stronger flour. A flour weaker than the plan needs tends to go slack and sticky before baking day.
Malted or not: why a 00 pizza can stay pale at home
King Arthur's bakery bread and all-purpose flours are malted: a little malted barley is added, which supplies enzymes that turn starch into sugar for the yeast and for browning. Caputo Pizzeria lists only wheat flour. In a pizza oven that does not matter; the heat browns the crust in seconds. In a home oven, an unmalted 00 dough can brown less. The home-oven recipe adds 1% sugar and a little oil for that reason. Or use bread flour.
Wholemeal and rye
Bran and germ bring flavour, colour and extra food for yeast and bacteria, so wholegrain doughs tend to ferment faster. They also absorb more water, and the bran cuts through gluten, so the dough is weaker. A little in a white dough adds flavour at little cost; the everyday sourdough loaf uses 10%. Much more, and you will need more water and should expect a smaller, denser loaf.
Swapping flours in a recipe
- Stronger flour than the recipe: it can take more water. Ooni's guide gives 12 to 13% protein flours a range of 60 to 80% hydration, against 60 to 75% for 11 to 12%. Start with the recipe's water and add a little if the dough feels stiff.
- Weaker flour than the recipe: hold back some of the water, and consider a shorter ferment.
- New bag, same name: hold back a little water and add it once you feel the dough. Every flour absorbs differently.
Open the pizza dough calculator
Keep going
Sources
- King Arthur Baking: Protein percentage in flour
- King Arthur Baking: Professional bakery flour specifications
- Caputo Pizzeria Type 00: retailer specification
- Caputo: The different types of flour
- Ooni: Hydration, fermentation time and protein content
- Associazione Verace Pizza Napoletana, International Regulation (2024)
- Everything not linked above is Ovenmark's own working, explained on How we work it out.