Poolish and biga: the head start that changes the dough
A preferment is a small part of the dough mixed hours ahead with a pinch of yeast. By mixing time it is full of flavour, acidity and enzymes that would take a straight dough far longer to build. Poolish is wet; biga is stiff. They push the dough in different directions.
The two side by side
| Poolish | Biga | |
|---|---|---|
| Water | Equal weight to the flour (100%) | About half the flour's weight (45 to 55%) |
| Looks like | A thick, bubbly batter | Dry, shaggy lumps that barely hold together |
| Share of the flour in these formulas | 30% | 50% |
| Time in the calculator | 8 to 16 hours | 12 to 24 hours, ideally somewhere cool |
| Flavour, as King Arthur describes it | Nutty, with a dough that stretches easily | Floral and aromatic |
| Handling | Dissolves easily into the dough water | Stiff, so it takes more work to mix in evenly |
Which is better? The Modernist Bread team baked them side by side and found them largely interchangeable: the flavour differences were, in their words, "exceedingly subtle at best." The real difference is handling. A poolish whisks straight into the dough water; a stiff biga has to be broken up and worked in. Choose poolish if you mix by hand, biga if you like a firmer dough or simply want to try it. Both are yeast preferments, not sourdough: they use a pinch of commercial yeast and are made fresh each time.
Why a preferment works
In the hours before mixing, the yeast multiplies, enzymes in the flour break starch into sugars and proteins into a softer gluten, and bacteria make the acids that give bread its depth. Mix that into fresh flour and the final dough starts life mature. You get the flavour and handling of a long ferment, with a shorter final rise.
The water level changes the pace. King Arthur gives 12 to 16 hours for a preferment. The calculator allows a poolish 8 to 16 hours and a biga 12 to 24, and sizes the yeast to fit. A stiff biga ferments more slowly than a wet poolish; Ovenmark assumes about 30% more slowly, a rule of thumb rather than a measured figure, and gives it more time or a little more yeast.
Formula 1: poolish, for a home oven
Four 260 g balls, Neapolitan-style for a home oven, for dinner at 7 PM the next day. 30% of the flour goes into the poolish. From the pizza calculator at a 70°F (21°C) kitchen:
| When | What | Weights |
|---|---|---|
| 7:00 AM, day 1 | Mix the poolish: stir the yeast into the water, add the flour, mix to a smooth batter. Cover, leave on the counter. | 180 g flour, 180 g water, 0.27 g instant yeast |
| 6:45 PM | Mix the dough: whisk the poolish into the water, add the flour and yeast, then the salt, oil and sugar. Knead as normal. | 419 g flour, 222 g water, 1.0 g instant yeast, 17 g salt, 15 g oil, 6 g sugar |
| 9:05 PM | Shape four balls, into the fridge. | |
| 3:45 PM, day 2 | Take the dough out. Bake from 6:45. |
Total: 599 g flour and 402 g water, 67% hydration, exactly the same dough as the home-oven recipe with part of it made ahead.
Formula 2: biga, for a pizza oven
Four 260 g balls of classic Neapolitan dough at 62% for a pizza oven. 40% of the flour goes into the biga, started the evening before:
| When | What | Weights |
|---|---|---|
| 10:45 PM, day 1 | Mix the biga: dissolve the yeast in the water, add the flour and toss with your fingers until all the flour is damp. Do not knead. Leave it as rough lumps, covered. | 252 g flour, 126 g water, 0.20 g instant yeast |
| 6:45 PM, day 2 | Mix the dough: tear the biga into small pieces into the water, add the flour and yeast, mix, then add the salt. Knead until smooth. | 378 g flour, 265 g water, 0.9 g instant yeast, 18 g salt |
| 9:05 PM | Shape four balls, into the fridge. | |
| 3:45 PM, day 3 | Take the dough out. Bake from 6:45. |
The biga in this plan has 20 hours at room temperature, so it needs only a pinch of yeast. If your plan gives it fewer hours, or a cooler room, the calculator raises the yeast to match.
How to tell it is ready
| Ready | Too young | Too old | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Poolish | Domed and covered in bubbles, some just starting to pop. Smells sweet and yeasty, like beer. | Flat, few bubbles, smells of raw flour | Dome collapsed with a tide line on the jar. Sharp, boozy or nail-polish smell |
| Biga | Clearly grown and domed, soft inside with a web of small holes when torn. Smells sweet and lightly alcoholic. | Still dense and floury inside | Wet and sticky, smells strongly of alcohol or vinegar |
A preferment past its best makes a slack, sticky dough that browns too fast. If yours is over, use it anyway but shorten the final rise, or put it in the fridge for an hour to slow it while you get ready.
Mistakes a pizzaiolo sees most
- Forgetting to count it. The flour and water in the preferment are part of the dough. A recipe that says "67% hydration" must include them, or you will add too much water. The calculator always does.
- Kneading the biga. It should be a rough, crumbly mass. Kneading it into a smooth ball makes it ferment unevenly.
- Putting it somewhere warm. On top of the fridge or next to the oven, a poolish can be over in six hours. Find a steady spot away from heat.
- Adding the salt to the preferment. Salt slows yeast. Keep it for the final dough, and add it after the flour is mixed in.
Try it in the calculator
In the pizza dough calculator, open "Change the dough", then "Rise", and choose Poolish or Biga under "Made first". It sizes the preferment, picks a start time inside your waking hours, and splits the yeast between the preferment and the dough.
Open the pizza dough calculator
Keep going
Sources
- King Arthur Baking: Baking with preferments
- Modernist Bread: Are biga, poolish, and sponge interchangeable?
- Everything not linked above is Ovenmark's own working, explained on How we work it out.